Two of the Biggest Misconceptions About Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)

"CBT is uniquely equipped to address both current symptoms and the deeper predispositions and vulnerabilities rooted in past experiences ... In this more comprehensive approach to care, clients are not only more likely to get well, they are more likely to stay well."

There are several Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) myths or misconceptions that I have encountered in providing training and in reading articles about CBT.

In this article, I identify two common misconceptions and explain why they are inaccurate representations of the therapy.

MYTH #1: "This therapy ignores the past and only focuses on the present."

A common misconception among those unfamiliar with CBT (or among professionals from other schools of therapy) is that it is a superficial approach, concerned only with current "thoughts" and "behaviors" while paying little attention to a client's history. In reality, there is a great deal more to CBT than simply targeting immediate thoughts and behaviors. 

Therapists who practice CBT competently (and follow the model as intended) will, at the appropriate point in therapy, explore what predisposed a client to think or react to situations in the way that they do. At this stage, the client and therapist work together to examine how certain patterns developed — and learn how those patterns continue to make the client vulnerable to distress in different ways. 

What makes CBT distinct is that while it does explore the past, it also equips clients with focused, practical tools to manage their current challenges and day-to-day distress.

It could be argued that ignoring the relief of debilitating symptoms (such as panic attacks) in favor of explorative therapy focused on the childhood origins of psychopathology is not just an ineffective strategy, but a major disservice to clients. CBT, in contrast, involves an early phase in which the therapist helps the client deal with the impairing depressive symptoms or panic attacks that brought them in for help. Once these symptoms are reduced, eliminated, or brought under better control, a later phase of therapy can then focus on exploring how the client became vulnerable to developing these issues based on the messages or experiences they encountered in their past, whether recent or distant. 

Research suggests that this phase of therapy (which examines predisposing factors and vulnerabilities) is important for preventing relapse and maintaining progress. Consider a client whose depressive symptoms have improved, but who still carries a deep-seated belief that "I need to be perfect," rooted in a history of growing up with a highly critical parent. If this underlying belief is not addressed later in therapy, once the depressive symptoms have been successfully treated, that client remains at risk for a recurrence of depression down the road. 

"When Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) became a major revolution in psychotherapy, many of its critics who failed to understand what it involved labeled it as simply a therapy aimed at having individuals think more positively. This involves a serious and damaging misconception."

To illustrate this two-pronged approach, consider a CBT client who presented with significant anxiety across a variety of situations – including a fear of getting sick, a fear of travel, and a fear of crowds. In the early phase of treatment, CBT helped him recognize and challenge the catastrophic thoughts driving his anxiety, particularly the belief that "I am in danger." These thoughts had been fueling not only his anxiety, but his avoidance of travel, crowds, and medical appointments. Armed with tools to combat his anxiety, addressing both his thinking patterns and his physical responses, his symptoms began to improve significantly.

Once his symptoms were under better control, therapy shifted to exploring the origins and maintenance of his core belief that the world was a dangerous place. What emerged was telling: growing up, his mother had repeatedly warned him that the world was very dangerous and that terrible things could happen at any time.

As a result, he had grown up feeling vulnerable and at risk in a wide range of situations. Through therapy, he came to recognize that while his mother had good intentions and was simply being overprotective, her warnings had helped create a pattern of irrational anxiety in him. This understanding gave him a clearer lens through which to examine his own anxious thinking.

From there, he was able to develop a revised belief about safety and danger, one grounded in a more realistic appraisal of risk. Rather than treating most situations as inherently threatening, his new belief allowed him to make more measured judgments: "I will avoid obviously dangerous situations, but I will estimate the actual risk before I decide about certain situations." This shift protected him where it mattered, without the overgeneralization that had previously caused him to fear even objectively safe situations.

CBT is uniquely equipped to address both current symptoms and the deeper predispositions and vulnerabilities rooted in past experiences. When treatment attends to both, the long-term outcomes are stronger and the risk of relapse is significantly reduced. In this more comprehensive approach to care, clients are not only more likely to get well, they are more likely to stay well.

MYTH #2 : "CBT encourages clients to substitute negative with positive thinking."

Back in the 1950s, a writer named Norman Vincent Peale became famous for a best-selling self-help book called The Power of Positive Thinking. Many years later, when Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) became a major revolution in psychotherapy, many of its critics who failed to understand what it involved labeled it as simply a therapy aimed at having individuals think more positively.

This involves a serious and damaging misconception.

Research has shown that negative thinking plays a significant role across a wide range of mental health disorders including depression, anxiety, and phobias. However, CBT is not simply about getting rid of these thoughts or replacing them with positive ones. In fact, overly positive thinking carries its own risks, leaving people vulnerable to disappointment when reality does not match their expectations.

"A common misconception among those unfamiliar with CBT is that it is a superficial approach ... In reality, there is a great deal more to CBT than simply targeting immediate thoughts and behaviors."

Even if it were possible to eliminate negative thoughts entirely, doing so would not always be appropriate. Consider a client who has the thought that their partner is angry with them and feels upset as a result. A CBT therapist would not immediately label this thought as negative, biased, or untrue — nor would they encourage the client to simply think differently. Instead, the therapist would work with the client to examine the evidence. If the evidence supported the thought, the focus would shift to how to repair the situation and address the real-life problem at hand. If little or no evidence supported it, the goal would be to explore what is actually going on rather than assuming the worst and jumping to conclusions.

At its core, CBT helps clients work through three essential steps:

1. Identify the thoughts that are causing them distress.
2. Examine and test those thoughts in a variety of ways.
3. Move forward productively, either by updating their thinking in light of new information or by finding constructive ways to cope with a genuinely stressful situation that is contributing to their emotional upset.

In some situations where it is obvious that a client's thoughts are valid or accurate (for example, when someone in their past has clearly let them down or not treated them fairly) the therapist might have the client consider what negative effects holding onto these thoughts could have on their emotional state.

There are numerous other strategies to help clients with their negative thinking, but the bottom line is this: CBT is not a therapy that teaches clients to think positively. Rather, it helps them think realistically and in a more functional, healthy way.

Want to make the most of everything Impact CE has to offer?

The Ignite Membership unlocks unlimited live webinars, hundreds of self-paced courses, a growing library of recorded content, and free e-library access — all in one place, for one low annual price. Learn more about Ignite today.