Power Dynamics in Youth Work: Why Today’s Young People Need a Different Kind of Adult

"Instead of immediately asking, ‘Why won’t you put that phone down?’ we sometimes need to ask another question: ‘What is happening on the phone that feels important right now?'" 

Power Dynamics in Youth Work

104789 Power Dynamics in Youth Work

Live Event
Sat, Dec 12th, 2026
9:00am – 11:00am US Pacific Time
2 CE Hours Youth, Therapeutic Relationship

This training will provide youth workers, educators, community leaders, and mental health professionals with a comprehensive understanding of power dynamics in youth work. Participants will examine how power structures and identity factors influence relationships, communication, decision-making, and outcomes in youth-focused environments. Particular attention will be given to the ways race, gender, socioeconomic status, and adult-youth power differences can shape engagement...

 

Adults enter relationships with young people, holding power through age, role, institutional authority, access to resources, rules, knowledge, and decision-making. This power is not inherently harmful. Young people need adults who can provide safety, structure, boundaries, guidance, and accountability. The problem arises when authority is mistaken for superiority or when compliance becomes the primary measure of a successful relationship.

Youth work is developmental work. The relationship is not a side issue. It's part of the intervention. My training on power dynamics shows that we set rules, control resources, interpret behavior, decide consequences, or define what “help” looks like. The real question is whether our power protects dignity, builds capacity, and supports mental and emotional health. 

That question matters even more to today's young people. 

 

Teenage girl sitting on armchair and talking about her problems to psychologist during consultation at office.

 

As youth work expands into schools, community programs, child welfare systems, and mental health services, it is unfolding in an environment different from what many of us expected. Youth are navigating constant connectivity, algorithm-driven media, public social comparison, rapid cultural change, pandemic disruption, and generative artificial intelligence. These conditions do not automatically make young people weaker, disrespectful, or less capable. They mean the environment shaping their development has changed. Our practice must change with it.

Understanding Generation Alpha

Generation Alpha makes this shift especially visible. Generational boundaries are not exact, but the term commonly refers to children born around 2010 and extending into the mid-20s. McCrindle research, which coined the term, uses 2010 through 2024, while other sources use slightly different dates. It notes that the oldest members of this generation are now entering their mid-adolescent years.

Broadly, Gen Z grew up with the rise of smartphones, social media, streaming, and digital communication. Generation Alpha enters a world where these things were already normal; a touchscreen is not new technology to them. Streaming is not an alternative to television. An online community is not necessarily separate from a quote UN quote. Increasingly, artificial intelligence is not futuristic technology either. It is something they can use for homework, information, creativity, companionship, and problem-solving.

The numbers help illustrate the shift. Common Sense Media's 2025 census found that 40% of children had a tablet by age 2 and nearly one in four had a personal cell phone by age 8. Gaming among young children increased sharply between 2020 and 2025, while short-form video became more prominent. In 2026, Pew Research Center found that just over half of US teens had an AI chatbot for help with schoolwork, while 12% reported using chatbots for emotional support.

That last point should especially draw the attention of youth workers and mental health professionals. A young person may enter our office carrying not only the influence of family, friends, school, and social media but also advice, interpretations, and emotional responses generated by an algorithm.

Authority Has Changed

The environment changes the power relationship between youth and adults.

Adults no longer control access to information the way previous generations did. A young person can search, compare, record, post, fact-check, create content, build community, and challenge an adult's explanation within seconds.

Trying to respond by increasing control will not address that reality. We have to build credibility differently.

Authorities today must become more relational, transparent, and accountable. Young people may be asking us, directly or indirectly: Why is this rule necessary? Who made this decision? Why do you get to decide? Do you actually listen to me?

This is where adultism matters. Adultism occurs when adults' perspectives are treated as inherently more valid simply because adults are older. Positive youth development offers a different approach. Young people are not merely recipients of services. They are active participants in their own development. Meaningful youth engagement gives young people opportunities to make decisions, take responsibility, contribute, and influence outcomes.

My power CR continuum moves from no youth participation and tokenism toward consultation, common representation, mentoring, and partnership. At the partnership level, youth and adults help set agendas and make decisions, co-create activities, and share accountability.

That does not mean adults disappear. Sharing power is not the same as surrendering responsibility.

There will always be decisions involving safety, ethics, legal responsibilities, clinical judgments, or organizational boundaries that adults must make. Good practice is transparent about those limits while exerting genuine influence whenever possible.

Digital Life is Real Life

Mental health professionals must also stop treating digital life as separate from real life. For many young people, digital spaces are social environments where belonging, rejection, identity, reputation, conflict, learning, creativity, and help-seeking occur. My training reminds practitioners not to see phones only as rule violations, but as part of a social world people are trying to navigate.

That does not mean ignoring digital risk. The American Psychological Association recommends developmentally appropriate social media use, active adult coaching for younger adolescents, and social media literacy education. Similarly, UNICEF cautions against reducing technology to a simple “good versus bad” argument. Outcomes depend heavily on what young people do online, what they encounter there, and whether they have the skills and relationships needed to navigate those experiences safely. 

Instead of immediately asking, “Why won't you put that phone down?” we sometimes need to ask another question: “What is happening on the phone that feels important right now?” 

Who can hold the boundary and remain curious? 

Behavioral Is Data

The same principle applies beyond technology.

Trauma, chronic stress, rejection, discrimination, and prior experiences with adults can shape how young people interpret authority. A correction that seems minor to an adult can register very differently in a young person's nervous system. My training frames this simply: trauma can make adult power feel dangerous, creating cycles in which a youth's survival response is met with greater adult control, causing trust to erode and conflict to escalate.

This is why I encourage practitioners to shift from “what is wrong with this young person?” to “what might this young person be experiencing?”

That does not remove accountability. Behavior still has consequences. Limits still matter. But behavior also gives us information. Defiance may represent an attempt to regain control. Withdrawal may provide protection from exposure. Humor may redirect attention away from discomfort. Aggression may emerge from a perceived threat.

Understanding the need behind behavior helps choose an alternative that teaches rather than simply controls.

A Different Kind of Adult

Today's young people do not need passive adults. They do not need permissiveness disguised as empowerment. They need adults who regulate enough to exercise authority responsibly. 

They need boundaries without humiliation. Accountability without domination. Voice with genuine influence. Choice where it is possible. Explanation when adults must make the final decision. And repair when adults get something wrong.

Youth development has long distinguished itself among services provided to young people, supports created with young people, and opportunities in which young people become active participants. Services matter, but services alone are not enough. Young people also need safety, belonging, contribution, independence, competence, trusting relationships, and opportunities to exercise meaningful responsibility.

Generation Alpha is not a problem for us to solve. It is a generation developing within a social ecology. If their environment has changed while our approach to youth work has remained the same, the mismatch is ours to address.

The future of youth work will require greater digital literacy, cultural humility, emotional intelligence, developmental awareness, and a willingness to share appropriate power. Young people still need guidance, structure, and boundaries. They absolutely still need adults. But they increasingly need adults to understand that our strongest influence does not come from controlling young people. It comes from using our power to build safety, agency, competence, connection, dignity, and trust. ◼

Power Dynamics in Youth Work

104789 Power Dynamics in Youth Work

Live Event
Sat, Dec 12th, 2026
9:00am – 11:00am US Pacific Time
2 CE Hours Youth, Therapeutic Relationship

This training will provide youth workers, educators, community leaders, and mental health professionals with a comprehensive understanding of power dynamics in youth work. Participants will examine how power structures and identity factors influence relationships, communication, decision-making, and outcomes in youth-focused environments. Particular attention will be given to the ways race, gender, socioeconomic status, and adult-youth power differences can shape engagement...


Want to make the most of everything Impact CE has to offer?

The Ignite Membership unlocks Premium events and Masterclasses, Unlimited Live Webinars, Hundreds of Self-Paced Courses, a Growing Library of Recorded Content, and Free E-Library access — all in one place, for one low annual price. Learn more about Ignite today.

Sources

McCrindle Research. Generation Alpha Defined. https://mccrindle.com.au/article/topic/generation-alpha/generation-alpha-defined/

Common Sense Media. (2025). The Common Sense Census: Media Use by Kids Zero to Eight. https://www.commonsensemedia.org/research/the-2025-common-sense-census-media-use-by-kids-zero-to-eight

Pew Research Center. (2026). How Teens Use and View AI. https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2026/02/24/how-teens-use-and-view-ai/

American Psychological Association. Health advisory on social media use in adolescence. https://www.apa.org/topics/social-media-internet/health-advisory-adolescent-social-media-use

About the author

Brandon Jones

Brandon Jones, MA, CPPM

Brandon Jones, MA, CPPM, is a mental health and leadership consultant, educator, and advocate dedicated to helping professionals and communities work in healthier, more purposeful ways. With a background in teaching, executive leadership, and cross-sector collaboration, he specializes in Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs), historical and intergenerational trauma, social–emotional intelligence, leadership development, and the Intercultural Development Inventory (IDI). Brandon holds a BA in Sociology from the University of Minnesota, a master’s degree in Community Psychology from Metropolitan State University, and a master’s degree in Psychotherapy (Marriage and Family Therapy) from Adler Graduate School. As a 2013 Bush Foundation Leadership Fellow, he brings both research-based insight and grounded lived experience to his work with organizations, educators, and mental health professionals. Guided by the personal motto, “Live life with purpose, on purpose,” Brandon continues to help individuals and systems move toward growth, clarity, and long-term well-being.

Opinions and viewpoints expressed in this article are the author's, and do not necessarily reflect those of CE Learning Systems.

Start your CE Journey now - complete your first course today, on us.

Try for free - no commitment required.

Copyright © 2026 CE Learning Systems LLC

Please Confirm